Tyler Warren is already rewriting history.
The Colts’ rookie tight end entered Week 6 leading all NFL tight ends in receiving yards (not just rookies) with 307 through five games.
Then he went out and did it again: six more catches, 63 more yards, and a touchdown.
Warren has now scored in back to back weeks and leads all rookie tight ends in first downs, explosive plays, and overall production.
At this point, “impressive for a rookie” doesn’t apply anymore. He’s been flat out dominant.
A Rookie Season for the Record Books
GettyColts Rookie TE Tyler Warren
Warren’s 17 first downs are the most by any rookie tight end in the PFF era (since 2006). His 2.81 yards per route run against zone coverage ranks second among all tight ends in the NFL. And through six weeks, he’s tied for the most 15 plus yard receptions ever by a rookie tight end in PFF’s database.
That’s not supposed to happen. Historically, tight ends need a full season, sometimes two, before they even sniff that kind of production. Over the past decade, fewer than half of all tight ends drafted in the first three rounds have topped 100 receiving yards in their first five games.
Warren hit 307.
Of course, the league isn’t short on young tight end talent. Brock Bowers shattered rookie records last season in Las Vegas, and Sam LaPorta’s breakout year in Detroit before that changed the way teams view the position.
But what Warren is doing in Indianapolis stands right alongside those names. It took Bowers until Week 9 to reach 10 explosive plays of 15 plus yards. Warren got there by Week 5.
Where most of today’s tight ends live detached from the formation, Warren is old school in all the right ways. Of the top five tight ends in receiving yards this season, he’s the only one who lines up in line more than 40% of the time.
And he’s not just there for show. Warren owns a 72.7 PFF blocking grade, fifth best among tight ends with 100 or more blocking snaps. That’s a massive leap from his final year at Penn State, when his blocking ranked outside the top 100 in the Power Four conferences.
Shane Steichen’s offense uses that versatility to its full extent: seam routes, flat concepts, screen game, even the occasional short yardage carry. Warren’s skill set lets the Colts toggle between spread formations and downhill, smash mouth football without substituting.
A Star in the Making
GettyColts Rookie TE Tyler Warren
The tight end position demands everything: blocking, running routes, vision, and trust. Most rookies spend their first season trying to survive.
Tyler Warren, on the other hand, already looks like he belongs. What separates him isn’t just the numbers (as crazy as they are), it’s the way he’s changed the flow of the Colts’ offense.
At 5-1, the Colts are one of the surprise stories of the NFL season. Most of the praise has gone to Daniel Jones, but dig a little deeper, and you’ll find that Warren has been one of the biggest reasons it’s all working.
He’s become Jones’ security blanket, mismatch creator, and drive extender. Warren is redefining what a rookie tight end can be and in the process, helping redefine what the Colts can become.
Indianapolis didn’t just find a complementary weapon.
They found a game changer.
They found the NFL’s next generational tight end.