Colin Cowherd Sparks Outrage with Wild Jared Goff Take Before Lions-Chiefs Showdown
Sunday’s showdown between the Detroit Lions and Kansas City Chiefs pits two of the league’s top quarterbacks, Jared Goff and Patrick Mahomes, in a potential Super Bowl 60 preview.
If you ask Fox Sports’ Colin Cowherd, though, he sees it as a battle of future Hall of Fame quarterbacks.
With three Super Bowl rings and no shortage of accolades on his resume, Mahomes has all but clinched his bronze bust in Canton. But you’d be hard-pressed to find many who would even consider Goff, who turns 31 on Oct. 14, to be on the verge of earning a spot in the Hall of Fame.
“No question, he’s gonna be a Hall of Famer,” Cowherd nonetheless argued on Wednesday. “He plays in rhythm, he plays in structure, he’s got great genetics ... Jared Goff is going to be a Hall of Famer.”
We won’t fault Cowherd for buying high on Goff, who enters Week 6 leading the NFL in completion percentage (75.2%) and touchdowns (12). Most importantly, the NFC North-leading Lions are 4-1, and Goff has only thrown two picks in 145 attempts.
Cowherd is free to feel optimistic about Goff and the Lions’ title chances, but the Hall of Fame is another conversation entirely.
Jared Goff Is Nowhere Close to Being a Hall of Fame Quarterback
Most football fans would likely agree that of the sport’s active quarterbacks, Mahomes and Aaron Rodgers are the only Hall of Fame locks. Matthew Stafford should join them, though we won’t be surprised to see some voters hold off. And while they might not be there
Then, there’s Goff. Pro Football Reference has a metric aptly called the Hall of Fame Monitor, which measures everything from traditional counting stats, like touchdowns or interceptions, to awards and All-Pro selections. Regardless of position, most Hall of Fame players score at least 100. For example, Tom Brady leads all quarterbacks with a 263.03 HOFm score, and even his biggest critics will agree he’s Hall of Fame-bound in a few years.
The average Hall of Fame quarterback scores at least a 108, and 11 quarterbacks have topped that number. Mahomes, at 102.08, could become the 12th within the coming months. Eight of the 11 are already in the Hall of Fame, and Drew Brees (140.58) is eligible to join them next year. Brady and Rodgers (197.91) will eventually have bronze busts, too.
Goff’s 47.95 HOFm ranks 57th among quarterbacks, putting him right below Raiders great Jim Plunkett’s 47.99. The only quarterback with a HOFm score under 60 is Buffalo Bills legend Jim Kelly, who finished at 59.10.
Is It Too Late for Jared Goff to Make the Hall of Fame?
We mentioned Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson, so it’s worth pointing out that Allen sits at 60.13, and Jackson is already at 81.40. It’s hard to see voters keeping either player out if they win a Super Bowl.
It might be too late for Goff, though. Eli Manning (86.01) has two Super Bowl rings, and there are still doubts about whether he’ll earn induction. Ken Anderson (82.99) hasn’t come close, and Cam Newton (70.50) isn’t a Hall of Famer. Then, you start getting into guys like Boomer Esiason (67.93), Joe Theismann (66.35), and Roman Gabriel (65.80), who, while they were fine quarterbacks, won’t be confused with Hall of Famers.
This isn’t even about advanced metrics, though. Football fans looked at Brady, Peyton Manning, and Joe Montana and knew they were watching Hall of Famers. Outside of Cowherd, does anyone say that about Goff?
To be clear: Goff has had a fine career, and he has the Lions on track to eventually win their first Super Bowl. But by no means is Goff on a Hall of Fame path, and that’s fine. Lions fans will love him either way if he brings a long-awaited title to Detroit.
NFL Expert: 'Seahawks Won't Let This Sneaky Showdown Against Jaguars Slip Away!'
As the Seattle Seahawks prepare for their Week 6 showdown against the Jacksonville Jaguars, NFL experts are divided, but one thing is clear — the Seahawks are determined not to let this game slip away. With both teams showcasing strong performances in the 2025 season, this game could be a pivotal moment for Seattle’s playoff hopes.
"NO ONE CAN PREDICT HOW THIS GAME WILL END, BUT I BELIEVE THE SEAHAWKS WILL CAPITALIZE ON THE OPPORTUNITY TO KEEP WINNING," said one expert. "Even though the Jaguars have a strong lineup, Seattle has been consistently impressive this season. They are in a rhythm that they’ll refuse to break, and I’m confident they’ll secure the win."
The Seahawks come into this game riding the momentum of their latest victories and a solid record. Under the leadership of coach Pete Carroll, Seattle has maintained a steady performance, especially with the explosive playmaking ability of quarterback Geno Smith and their defense's ability to bend but not break. The Seahawks are well-aware of the potential upset the Jaguars could bring, but the team remains laser-focused and determined to prove their dominance.
Jacksonville, on the other hand, enters Week 6 with a strong defensive showing and an offense that has come alive. Led by second-year quarterback Trevor Lawrence, the Jaguars have steadily grown into a formidable force. Despite their excellent record, the Jaguars' inconsistency has been a concern — especially with their tendency to struggle in high-pressure moments. This will likely be their biggest test of the season, as they look to upset Seattle on their home turf.
But Seahawks fans need not worry. According to experts, Seattle’s consistency and mental toughness will be key in this matchup. "Seattle has a way of staying calm under pressure," one NFL analyst commented. "Their defense will challenge Lawrence’s ability to make quick decisions, and I think the Seahawks will manage to outlast the Jaguars, capitalizing on the small opportunities Jacksonville gives them."
With the game being held at Lumen Field, the Seahawks will also have the advantage of a passionate home crowd, which has played a significant role in their past successes. The Seahawks are well-prepared and poised to continue their winning streak, focusing on executing their game plan with precision.
As the game approaches, this matchup is shaping up to be one of the most exciting and unpredictable of the week. With a strong defense, a proven quarterback, and a solid overall team effort, the Seahawks are poised to take down a talented but inconsistent Jaguars squad.
