Mel Kiper Jr. has once again unleashed strong criticism toward the Cleveland Browns, this time calling out the organization for what he views as its ongoing mishandling of quarterbacks.
Still frustrated months after the NFL Draft, Kiper has continued to defend Shedeur Sanders, who shockingly slid to the fifth round despite being considered a potential first-round selection.
The Browns eventually selected Sanders with the 144th overall pick, but the team’s coaching staff has continued to back third-rounder Dillon Gabriel as the starter. Speaking on ESPN’s First Draft podcast, Kiper didn’t hold back:
“Figure out Dillon Gabriel, that was Kevin Stefanski’s guy. Shedeur Sanders, Andrew Berry brought in because he was there in the fifth round, see what happens.”
Kiper believes the league mishandled Sanders entirely, arguing that his fall had more to do with perception than with his actual performance.
“To me organizations ruin QBs. You had Baker. Gabriel was Stefanski’s guy. I don’t care what the league says. I had Shedeur the #1 QB on my board last year. What happened? Nothing happened. They don’t want him."
Kiper’s frustration stems from what he sees as a familiar Cleveland pattern—drafting talented quarterbacks, then watching them fail under questionable team leadership.
Kiper says teams “ruin quarterbacks,” points to Browns’ long history
During the same podcast, Kiper doubled down, insisting that NFL teams often misjudge quarterbacks and sometimes destroy their potential through poor management. He noted that Sanders was viewed as the No. 1 quarterback prospect just a year ago while starring at Colorado. Yet, Kiper argued,
“Everybody’s clueless about quarterbacks including the National Football League geniuses, OK? They don’t know. Even when they have them, they don’t know. [The Browns] had Baker Mayfield, they let him go.”
Kiper revisited Cleveland’s turbulent quarterback history to make his case. Baker Mayfield, drafted first overall in 2018, helped the Browns reach an 11-5 record in 2020 and came within a game of the Super Bowl.
The team released him the following year, and he has since become a two-time Pro Bowler and an MVP candidate with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
Cleveland’s inconsistency speaks for itself—since 1999, the Browns have finished last in their division 15 times and secured just one playoff victory. Now, Kiper fears Sanders could become the next casualty in that cycle as the team prepares to face the New York Jets on November 9 at MetLife Stadium.


