Steelers Facing Criticism for Odd Decision in Bengals Loss
Posted October 19, 2025
There really wasn’t a single great individual performance from the Pittsburgh Steelers defense against the Cincinnati Bengals on Thursday. But in edge rusher Nick Herbig’s case, it may have been due to the lack of opportunity.
Herbig played 29 defensive snaps for the Steelers versus their division rival in Week 7. That was 38% of the team’s snaps on defense in the matchup.
Steelers Depot’s Joe Clark argued that was far too low.
“I can understand some of the reasoning. It’s a short week. Herbig had played a lot on Sunday, and the team might not want to wear him down too early,”
Clark wrote. “The Steelers got off to a bad start against the run, and Alex Highsmith has been a better run defender. But I just don’t really get the justification for having him player 26 fewer snaps than Highsmith.
“For one, Highsmith is coming off an ankle injury, which he returned from in Week 6. Highsmith probably could’ve used the rest more than the younger and healthier Herbig, and Herbig has just been so dynamic as a pass rusher this year that he needs to be playing more.”
Herbig has 4.5 sacks, six tackles for loss and 13 quarterback hits this season. He’s leads the Steelers in all three categories, and unlike All-Pros defenders T.J. Watt and Cameron Heyward, Herbig missed a game in September.
Steelers Pass Rush Struggles Against Bengals
The Steelers recorded two sacks versus Cincinnati in Week 7. However, quarterback Joe Flacco was far too comfortable for most of the night and tore apart the Pittsburgh secondary.
Flacco delivered a lot of short, quick passes. But the Steelers were also unable to generate much pressure when they had opportunities.
Watt, Heyward and Alex Highsmith all played at least 70% of the team’s defensive snaps in the contest. Yet, they combined for just one sack and two quarterback hits.
Highsmith recorded three tackles and no other statistics.
In limited playing time, Herbig posted two tackles and one quarterback hit.
The Steelers appeared to try a lot of different coverages to try and slow down the Bengals elite receivers Thursday. But the team made few adjustments to their defensive front during the game. That resulted in Herbig not getting a lot of playing time.
That was surprising given that he came into the game with a sack in three straight contests. Just four days prior, Herbig had two sacks and four quarterback hits in Week 6.
How Do Steelers Get Nick Herbig More Playing Time?
As head coach Mike Tomlin has said, needing to find more playing time for Herbig is a “good problem to have.” However, it’s still a problem nonetheless.
It’s an issue that Clark argued the Steelers are still trying to figure out.
“The Steelers had Herbig on the field with Highsmith and Watt in their Bronco package four times on Thursday, per Alex Kozora’s charting,”
Clark wrote. “Two of those plays led to incompletions, while two of them led to gains of 10+ yards through the air.
“But the Steelers went away from it for a large part of the game, and it’s something I’d like to see them experiment with more.”
If the Steelers aren’t going to deploy the three edge rushers together, then the team will have to take away playing time from someone else to get Herbig on the field.
That’s not ideal because Watt and Highsmith are elite edge rushers. But Herbig has arguably been Pittsburgh’s most impactful defender through seven weeks. He needs to be on the field, especially if Watt and Highsmith go silent.
The Steelers should ride the hot hand at every defensive position. No one is playing better for Pittsburgh’s defense than Herbig this season.
Carson Wentz and J.J. McCarthy Both on Vikings Injury Report for Week 8 Matchup
Carson Wentz happens to be dealing with some injury issues ahead of the Minnesota Vikings’ Week 8 matchup against the Los Angeles Chargers on Thursday night.
Wentz has been handling the starting quarterback duties since JJ McCarthy went down with an ankle injury. The veteran quarterback has helped Minnesota stay afloat after four starts, having a 2-2 record.
However, his latest contest against the Philadelphia Eagles had him pick up a left shoulder injury. He and McCarthy both carry limited participation statuses on Monday, per NFL insider Tom Pelissero.
“#Vikings QBs J.J. McCarthy (ankle) and Carson Wentz (left shoulder) were both listed as limited on today’s estimated injury report ahead of Thursday night’s game vs. the Chargers,” Pelissero wrote.
Team reporter Alec Lewis went further into the injury report. He showed a list of the report, which has Andrew Van Ginkel and Xavier Scott among others.
What lies ahead for Carson Wentz, Vikings
The Vikings find themselves in a tough spot with Carson Wentz and JJ McCarthy nursing injuries.
Wentz has been solid in his four starts, completing 95 passes out of 142 attempts for 1,072 yards and five touchdowns and four interceptions. His efforts helped Minnesota get wins over the Cincinnati Bengals and Cleveland Browns while sustaining losses to the Pittsburgh Steelers and Philadelphia Eagles.
McCarthy has been absent since Week 2 of the season. In the two starts he had, the second-year quarterback completed 24 passes out of 41 attempts for 301 yards and two touchdowns and three interceptions.
Minnesota has a 3-3 record on the season, being at the bottom of the NFC North Division standings. They trail the Chicago Bears, Detroit Lions and Green Bay Packers at the moment. In terms of the NFC standings, they sit at the 12th spot.
The Vikings will continue preparation for their Week 8 matchup against the Chargers. The contest will take place on Oct. 23 at 8:15 p.m. ET.
