Howie’s Hubris: How the Eagles’ Identity Vanished and Why It’s Not Just Saquon

Once the NFL’s gold standard for rushing dominance, the Philadelphia Eagles have fallen from historically great to historically lost because of a mix of injuries, front-office overconfidence, and schematic drift.  Translation: Their identity is gone.

The frustrating part isn’t just that the Eagles can’t get Saquon Barkley going.  It’s that every week they almost do, and then it vanishes.

In Denver, Barkley ripped off a 17-yard burst on his second carry. The rest of the game? Four carries, ten yards.  Against the Giants, he opened with runs of 18 and 13 yards — something he never even did back-to-back during his MVP-level 2024 season. After that? Ten carries for 27 yards.  In Minnesota, he had five carries for 25 yards on the opening drive, then thirteen for nineteen the rest of the night.

“I feel like in recent weeks we’ve been really good in the beginning, in the run game,” Barkley said Wednesday. “We kind of fall off after that, and that starts with me. I’ve got to be better.”

An Identity Gone Missing

---

Under head coach Nick Sirianni, the Eagles built their identity around trench dominance and balance. For four years, they bullied teams on the ground.

A year ago, the Eagles were the second-best rushing team in football, dominant, balanced, relentless and lethal.

Now? They’re bottom-five.  It’s painful to watch and Barkley’s production mirrors the collapse:

• 1st quarter: 5.1 yards per carry (4th-best in the NFL)
• Rest of game: 2.8 yards per carry

His overall 3.27 yards per rush is the lowest by any Eagles back through seven games since Swede Hanson in 1933, he team’s first year of existence.

Injuries, Absences, and a Costly Miscalculation

Sirianni called it “team football” and he’s right.  This isn’t just on Barkley. A lot of it traces back to Howie Roseman’s roster math.

The offensive line that once bulldozed opponents is now a mess.  It’s being held together by patchwork.  Landon Dickerson and Cam Jurgens have missed time, the depth behind them has been shaky at best, and the chemistry that defined the unit is gone.

Then came the Mekhi Becton mistake, a somewhat quiet decision with bellowing consequences.  Roseman let the massive guard walk to the Chargers for just $10 million per year, confident the Eagles’ developmental system would again produce ready replacements. The Eagles acquired former first round pick guard Kenyon Green from the Texans in a trade for safety C.J. Gardner-Johnson last March figuring that offensive line coach Jeff Stoutland could just work his magic like he did with Becton.  It didn’t work and after waiving Green twice in September, he is currently unemployed.  Becton’s size and edge toughness are badly missed, and the line looks less-than ordinary for the first time in years.

Howie’s Hubris

Roseman’s real misstep wasn’t losing players, it was believing he could replace greatness by formula.  After Jason Kelce and D’Andre Swift departed following the 2023 season, Roseman rebuilt on the fly.  He signed Barkley, tweaked the blocking pieces, and watched the new unit explode for over 3,000 rushing yards in 2024. It was a masterclass. But it fooled him, again.

He assumed the same developmental magic, injury luck, and player buy-in would happen again in 2025.  But the depth hasn’t progressed, at least not yet. What worked once through timing, chemistry and good fortune has disintegrated under assumption.

Inside Barkely’s Collapse

Physically, Barkley still looks like that guy he did last year, explosive, decisive, and violent in space.  But without holes, he’s pressing. He leads the NFL with 21 runs for negative yardage, accounting for nearly 19 percent of his carries, almost double his 2024 rate.

“I’ve got to do a better job of not taking negative runs,” he said. “I own the running game. That’s my responsibility. I was brought here to make plays in the run game, and I’m not making plays.”

It’s not fatigue. It’s not wear-and-tear from 482 touches last year he contends.  It’s structural.  The lanes are gone and he’s pressing because of it.

Where’d Who Go?

Against the Vikings, the Eagles became the first team in 11 years to win a game with 300-plus passing yards and fewer than 50 rushing yards.  Survive and advance.  That’s been Eagles football so far this year.  But high wire acts usually end up in chalk outlines and in the NFL if you can’t run the football consistently you’re in serious trouble long term.

The Birds’ record still says 5-2, but the identity has disappeared. The physical edge that once defined them, the pounding, relentless, clock-eating rhythm that gave defenses nightmares has left the building.

“People get caught up in how winning works,” Barkley said. “It’s not reality. This isn’t Madden. Whatever it looks like to win, that’s what we’ll keep doing.”

Fair enough King Saquon. But football has been around a while and the basic grass roots formula still works – running the ball and defense.  Those two elements have always traveled well and while you might be able to squeak by without them in the short term, over the long haul you’re doomed to collapse.  Last year the Birds finished 1st in defense, 2nd in rushing and 7th in passing.  That’s called elite balance.  Right now the Eagles are 28th in rushing, 26th in passing and 17th in overall defense.  If they don’t rediscover balance soon, the wins will stop coming.

Broad Street Bullied

The Eagles didn’t just lose their running game they lost their reflection.  From the NFL’s most complete offense to a one-dimensional team hoping its quarterback dons his cape every week, the decline has been fast, loud, and self-inflicted.  Until Philly rebuilds their offensive trenches and restores the physical identity that made them Super Bowl Champions last year, the Birds will continue to spin their wheels and have to rely on the passing game and special teams to bail them out weekly.  Unfortunately the bully keeps getting pushed around.

Are The Buccaneers Still ‘All In’ For 2025

Every year teams say that their goal is to win the Super Bowl. I mean what else are they going to say right? The truth is that typically teams build up momentum each season by building up their rosters smartly through the draft and then acquiring a few players via free agency.

Occasionally a team comes out of nowhere to win the Super Bowl but if you look at the last few seasons you’ll see the usual suspects  competing in the playoffs (KC, Philly, SF, Det, Buffalo, LA Rams and YES the Bucs). Going into this season the strengths of this team was the WRs, RBs, OL and QB. Even with a new OC the Buccaneers in theory had enough talent to score in the high 20’s.

Defense was where most of the improvement was needed. The lack of pass rush was seen as a huge weakness but the signing of Hassan Reddick was supposed to help. News flash, it hasn’t. They did do a great job of solidifying their secondary. By doubling down on CBs in the draft they not only added great depth but are set for the next 5 years. Now, the Bucs once strong units (WR, RB, OL) have been ravaged by injuries. Some players hopefully are coming back (Godwin, Bucky, Goedecke) while others aren’t (Evans, Mauch). In addition, their lone FA pass rusher is now set to miss multiple games. Remarkably the Bucs sit atop their division at 5-2. With the trade deadline approaching in a few weeks, the question is are the Bucs only 1 player away from a true SB run? Surely this is on the mind of their GM. Do they trade away high draft picks and go big game hunting or do they try and find some depth pieces from teams that have already turned the clock to the 2026 season?

—

Unfortunately I think they have sustained too many injuries to go after a truly impactfull player (assuming one is available). I do think they HAVE to bring in some depth at WR and OLB. This may cost a mid to late round pick. If Licht stands pat and does nothing then it may mean he is reluctant to surrender any draft capital. After a great start to the season, that would be akin to deflating a balloon. Here’s hoping that the Bucs can get relatively healthy after the Saints game. They’ll have a much needed bye week after that. Their next game comes after the trade deadline. We are about to find out what Licht really feels about his team very soon.

Continue reading